In Defense of Curiosity: Do We Have a Moral Imperative to Explore?

By Michael Baker

The Mars rover and mobile laboratory Curiosity touched down on the surface of the Red Planet early Monday morning, and already it’s being derided as a huge waste of resources.  With a $2.6 billion price tag, that’s to be expected.  But there’s a larger point that a lot of the detractors may be missing, and that’s the significance of this particular mission to space exploration, and to the quest for human knowledge.

That might sound pretty grandiose, but Peter Diamandis is arguing that as humans – as thinking, reasoning beings – we have a moral imperative to explore.  It’s not just that we have curiosity, it’s that we are morally obligated to have Curiosity.

Diamandis makes three basic points as part of his argument: that space holds resources that could be used to benefit us Earthlings and wipe out inequity, that space exploration allows us to “back up the biosphere” by leaving a footprint somewhere else in case we’re all eventually blown to bits, and that as humans we are genetically encoded to explore.

I’m not so sure that has me convinced.  There are lots of starving children in Africa who don’t have the desire to explore anything except their next meal, and for whom that $2.6 billion is far more than the resources that they need.  What does that say about moral imperatives?  Call me crazy, but things seem more imperative when they’re closer to home, and when the basis of comparison is Mars anything here on Earth would qualify.

Still, I don’t think Diamandis is completely off base about having an imperative to explore outer space; maybe it’s just not a moral one.  I think it’s by essence of our humanity that we feel the urge to find out what’s out there, and denying our own humanity is dishonest and counter-productive.  We gotta be us.

Ultimately, the human exploration of space is probably a search for meaning.  I’m not sure we’re going to find much meaning for Mankind out there among the sand and mountains of Mars, but it’s a pretty cool ride nonetheless.  The fact that the pictures that Curiosity has sent back so far look more like the landscape of the Mojave Desert than the surface of a rock 150,000,000 miles away is sort of reassuring.  It makes the Galaxy feel small, and that makes things that seemed impossible feel achievable.

4 comments

  1. Winston Churchill · · Reply

    Why do you think we have a moral obligation to help those that are not willing to help themselves? Why do you feel guilty about sacrificing your natural thirst for knowledge and truth because others are not willing to risk blood and treasure, as our forefathers did, to secure independence and freedom from a tyrannical government for themselves? If they don’t want it with every fiber of their being, why do you want it for them? Do they not have a moral obligation to themselves? No matter how much food or money you send these poor hungry people in Africa, do you not think that their corrupt self-serving governments aren’t going to snatch 95% of what you “try” to provide to the mistreated masses? We have here what we have because we fought for unalienable rights, but it sounds to me as though you’ve been propagandized by an ever growing presence of socialism in the public school system. People have the circumstances that they do because they’ve accepted it. No reason you should feel guilty for someone else’s decision. They own it. You don’t.

    1. First, you seem to have completely overlooked the point of this post. Second, you really think a starving child makes a conscious choice to accept his circumstances?

  2. Ceiling fans come in various designs, designs, form, and sizes.
    This model of Harbor Breeze Ceiling Fans is only priced at $109.
    You could take some pictures of the traditional ceiling fans you like – most shops
    won’t mind so long as you ask permission first.

  3. Winston · · Reply

    “Have nothing to do with the fruitless deeds of darkness, but rather expose them.” — Ephesians 5:11

    Yes, we have a moral imperative to investigate and expose.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 189 other followers

%d bloggers like this: